Bridesmaid Gifts - Choices, choices

So I am already well on my way with the bridesmaid gifts but I am having trouble rounding them out. Thus far my three lovely ladies will be receiving:

• Awesome weekend totes (and coordinating cosmetic pouch) made by my dear mom with Amy Butler fabrics.
• Pink Loves Brown pocket mirrors
• Aveda hand relief lotion (this sh*t is expensive but worth it)
• Polka dot nail file from BBW
• Silkscreened tank from Old Navy
• Custom belt to go with their dresses

I feel like I need more items, which of these do you think they would like the most?

• The stationery sets didn't work out so well so I am debating purchasing a few box sets from my favorite card designers and making an assortment box of sorts. I did already purchase the box mailers for the cards so I feel as if I should find a way to make them work.
• My bachelorette party is probably going to end up being more of a slumber party the Thursday before the wedding. So I thought pajama sets or tanks and lounge pants could be a cute idea.
• I have heard good things about CO Bigelow's Mentha Lip Shine, kind of ties up the lotion, mirror, etc.
• Cardigans in case it is chilly the day of the wedding, Chicago weather is unpredictable...
  

I want it to seem generous and have things they will really like without going too overboard...I am so bad at making decisions!!